The Fallacy of Free: Why Medicare for All Would Cost You More Than You Think

Compass Financial ManagementCommentary

Nothing in Government Is Ever Free

I have been saying this for years and I will keep saying it until people actually start listening. The word “free” is one of the most dangerous words in the political vocabulary. Every time a politician promises something free, what they are really doing is hiding the bill. They are just deciding who gets stuck with it later.

This whole Medicare for All push from Bernie Sanders and his allies like Ro Khanna is the latest version of the same old trick. Khanna is out there comparing Medicare for All to public school education, saying health care would be free for every American just like public school is free for every kid. I actually use that exact example with my own son. I pointed at his school and told him flat out: this is not free. Every neighbor on our street, every taxpayer in this community is paying for this building, these teachers, and these books. You owe it to all of them to work hard because they are funding your opportunity.

The Poll Problem Nobody Is Talking About

Bernie Sanders loves to wave around polls showing overwhelming support for Medicare for All. He wants you to believe the entire country is on board. Here is what those polls never include: the actual cost.

When you show people what Medicare for All would genuinely cost, the numbers change fast. This is not a new phenomenon. I lost a sixth grade class election to a girl who promised our entire class a trip to Disney World over spring break. My platform was a picnic and a softball game against a rival class. I never stood a chance. She won. We never went to Disney World. We were never going to Disney World. But it sounded great and people voted for it anyway.

That is exactly what is happening here on a national scale.

What the Real Numbers Actually Mean for Your Finances

Here is where this gets personal for every working American:

  • Payroll tax expansion is one of the primary funding mechanisms being floated for Medicare for All
  • Right now the payroll tax cap sits around $168,000. Proposals to eliminate or raise that cap would hit working professionals and small business owners hard
  • People earning $70,000 a year already pay payroll taxes on every dollar. The idea that this restructuring only hits the ultra-wealthy is a talking point, not a financial reality
  • Your current employer-sponsored benefits, the ones you have negotiated as part of your compensation, could be restructured or eliminated entirely under a government takeover of health insurance
  • Private insurance could theoretically still exist alongside Medicare for All, but history tells us government programs crowd out private competition over time

Why Voters Keep Falling for It

I watched people during COVID-19 who called themselves fiscal conservatives practically sprint to the mailbox waiting for their government checks. The minute the promise of free money hit, the ideology went right out the window. Self-interest overrides principled thinking almost every single time.

That is not a partisan observation. It is a human nature observation. Politicians know it, they exploit it, and they count on voters not doing the math.

What You Should Actually Be Doing Right Now

Regardless of which direction health care policy moves over the next few years, the lesson for your personal finances is clear:

  • Do not assume your current health benefits are permanent. Build flexibility into your financial plan.
  • Understand your true tax exposure. If payroll tax structures change, that affects your net take-home pay and your retirement contributions.
  • Model scenarios. What does your retirement picture look like if your effective tax rate increases by three, five, or even eight percent?
  • Stop relying on government promises as a planning tool. Build your own safety net through savings, investment, and diversification.

The fallacy of free is not just a political problem. It is a financial planning problem. Every time Washington promises something for nothing, real Americans end up absorbing costs they never saw coming. Plan accordingly.